Site of Gary Streeter MP for Devon South West

Gary's weekly views

Each week an article by Gary has appeared in the Plympton Plymstock and Ivybridge News in South West Devon. The articles are published here

SCOTLAND

Scotland has a population of just over 5 million and has been part of the United Kingdom since the Acts of Union in 1707. It gets about 30% more government spending per head than England under a formula thrashed out over 40 years ago. It has had its own Parliament since 1999 yet still sends 59 MPs to Westminster. The average number of constituents in a Scottish constituency is 55,000 – in England it is 70,000. Scottish MPs can currently vote on every law in the House of Commons even those, like education and health laws, which do not affect Scotland, yet English and Welsh MPs obviously have no vote in the Scottish Parliament. Between 40 and 50% of Scots at any one time want independence from the Union.

Is there a Scottish problem? I think there is.

I remain firmly committed to the United Kingdom and would hate to see Scotland leave us. The United Kingdom still plays a crucial role in global affairs and we would be diminished if Scotland went it alone. Yet English resentment is building up at the current settlement. I see it in my mailbag more and more. How can we put in place fairer arrangements without driving our northern cousins into full blown independence?

First of all, we have to reduce the number of Scottish MPs who sit in Westminster so that they represent seats the same size as ours. Naturally there would be political resistance to this, but it can no longer be fudged. After all there are 129 members of the Scottish parliament buzzing around the place as well.

Second, the case for only English and Welsh MPs voting on legislation that does not affect Scotland is becoming compelling. I do not want to introduce an English Parliament; I think that is daft, but a policy of English votes for English laws makes sense.

Finally, is it not time to review the Barnet formula that provides so much more financial support for the Scots than for us south of the border? If it could ever be justified, it no longer can. Why should NHS patients and school children in Scotland get more money spent on them than south of the border? If the Scots want to spend more, they should raise the money from their own taxes.

I hope the Union lasts for another 300 years. But it will only do so if it is fair to both sides.

posted by Gary on Saturday, July 26, 2008

 

Powered by Blogger